| How to Choose the
Best Rims for Your Car?
Wheels are probably the single most visible styling statement of a vehicle next to it's overall shape and colour - - it has often been said that
wheels make the car. At the very least the wheels of the vehicle are very visible
and are the perhaps the easiest visible change that a vehicle owner can make to
personalize a vehicle.
Now having stated all the obvious lets get down to
the nitty gritty.
The after-market is full of choices for wheels if anyone has been to an
after-market trade show you know what I mean, you wonder where all this
product comes from and where it all goes perhaps " they" dump them in the ocean to
make new Islands or something because there can't possibly be that many sold.
Well there are thousands made and thousands sold and like anything else "you get
what you pay for" there is a difference in quality so the buyer has to be aware
of what they are purchasing . The intended use cycle is what matters most.
The use or duty cycle that the wheel sees of course is the a direct
reflection on the type of driving that the car experiences. If the car is
mainly used on the track then usually the goal is to get the lightest wheel
possible to reduce the mass of the components that have to articulate over the road
surface is always a benefit to the vehicles potential performance but if the wheel
flexes it could adversely affect the handling of the vehicle and the loss
could be more than the benefit gained from the weight reduction . It could also
be at least slightly inconvenient if the wheel breaks from flexing too
much, (beyond the capabilities of the material that the wheel rim is made from). If the
wheel just has to roll down the 4 lanes every morning to work (at a blistering
50 k) and once in a while get up to highway speeds on weekends or late at night
then the duty cycle is pretty mild in comparison to the track use and having the
ultimate strongest lightest wheel on the market is not that critical
What the wheel is made of and how it is made has a lot to do with it's
strength and weight.
Back in the budding times of the auto when the term
horseless carriage was the rage, car wheels were made the same way that
carriage wheels were made, usually some wooden spokes of some sort with
metal reinforcing. As more strength was required the content of metal went up
until the all metal wheel was the standard. The spoked design stayed around
because of the way that the basic configuration of the spoke gave good strength with
minimal material use - - most of today's designs are modifications of the
original spoked wagon wheel and spoked bicycle wheel. Somewhere along the
way other materials were used to enhance the strength/weight aspect of the
wheel. As usual the development centered around racing and the quest for
performance. A very stiff strong and light weight material called magnesium was used for
wheels some years ago and the term "MAG" wheel stuck. The term is used a lot
of times to describe any sporty looking wheel no matter what it is made of.
Magnesium - - although stiff and strong is very susceptible to
corrosion -- pure magnesium will literally corrode while you look at it.
In fact pure Mag shavings when mixed with water reacts quickly enough to create Hydrogen gas
(which is highly explosive). There are a multitude of alloys of Magnesium
that are available however -- this is when different other metals or elements are
mixed with the base metal to change its properties.
So its not like your wheels will explode while the car is sitting in the driveway the next time
it rains. Most applications of Magnesium wheels over the years has been
reserved for aviation or racing.
Recently there are coatings and alloy combinations
that have made it possible to have a wheel that will stand up to the elements of
the street but they tend to be expensive partially due to the extra processes
needed to help stave off the damage of corrosion.
The next lightest material that has similar strength to Mag is aluminum
and a lot of factory wheels on vehicles are made of aluminum (when they
aren't steel) especially passenger cars. This material is a good durable material
for a wheel and it is substantially lighter than steel so there is a performance
advantage potential - - - we say potential because they are not always
lighter when they are large diameter and have thick stylish spokes some can weigh as
much as a steel wheel but the appearance factor enters into the picture here
and there is no contest when the alternative steel wheel needs a plastic or
chrome wheel cover to attempt to dress it up. At this point in time Aluminum is the
most versatile and cost effective material for wheels when you add in the
styling issue.
Are all aluminum wheels created equal ? No there are huge
differences in both the process and the alloy content of the metal of the
wheels on the market . The OE wheels tend to be made stronger and are made
of better alloys than a lot of the cheaper after-market product. (this is
liability generated effort ) There are standards that wheels have to be manufactured to. The
standards that a car manufacturer has to meet are much higher than what an
after-market wheel manufacturer has to meet. The OE has to make something like 300,000
cycles on a dynamic lateral loading test and the after-market only needs to pass
approximately half to get DOT approval. Not all after-market wheels have DOT
approval, it is not actually a requirement to sell wheels (for passenger
cars). The other type of approval is TUV which is the German DOT . Companies
that want to sell product in Germany have to have this rating on their
product -- but even some that have approval for Germany for some of the product - -
don't have a TUV approval for product sold outside of Germany.
I guess when you boil all of this down you get what you pay for and you
have to do a little research on who made the wheels if you want some
assurance of some reasonable quality.
If appearance and price are the only criteria
the wheels probably shouldn't experience the duty cycle of the race track or
your experience is liable to be a bad one. If you are buying for the street then
the overall strength may not be the #1 concern but the advice would be to stay
with a name brand that you recognize if you want to ensure some quality. If you
are in the habit of hitting big potholes at speed and jumping railway tracks and
curbs with low profile tires then you probably will bend a wheel no matter
who made it or what material the wheel is made of (that's why off road vehicles
have more balloon shaped tires to absorb the impact) If you are putting on
snows the factory wheels are just fine in steel or aluminum, some people
like to look for a cheap set of steel wheels for the snows to save the fancy wheels
for the summer rubber - - if you don't care about the appearance for the winter
this is an excellent plan - - it also affords you the flexibility of just
installing the wheel as a mounted unit in spring and fall rather than going
through the pain and expense of mounting and remounting the rubber on the
rim.
When talking to people in the after-market the single biggest problem
they have with wheels is inappropriate sizing and fitting. It is essential that
the wheel fits the car, the offset, and width, must be correct. The offset is
the in and out positioning of the wheel in relation to the bolt up surface. It
is obvious if the tire is rubbing on the fender lip or on the strut or any
other part of the suspension that this could be really wrong but a slight change
in and out will make the car feel differently. You may end up with the car
wanting to follow all the cracks in the pavement on the highway or not wanting to
negotiate corners. The handling was better before the installation of the
hot looking product that you just had installed because you couldn't get that
picture out of your head that you saw on the cover of the latest publication
and had to have them.
Now what ?? Don't always blame the product!
Remember it is a big compromise and when you change one thing other things are effected.
What this means is that the alignment of the vehicle might have to be set
slightly different than is says in the factory specs in order to compensate for the
different input that this new wheel and tire combination needs.
The factory spec's are generated based on the wheels and tires that they installed
-- if you do something different you may have set things up differently in order
to take advantage of the parts you are using. So the fast talking cheap tire
and wheel place may have the best price for the same product but if you are
going to change one of the dimensional parameters then you might be better purchasing
through someone who can re-adjust your suspension to suit even though it
costs a bit more for the wheels it may be worth it in the long run.
Balancing is another issue the same is true of the balancing and
installation of the wheel as the wheel itself , some shops are definitely better at this
than others. If you have a vibration on the steering wheel after the install of
the new wheels that wasn't there before then squawk -- if you have invested in
at least a reasonable level of quality wheel and tire they should run as smooth
as the factory stuff when you picked up the car new or better depending on
your dealer - they are not all created equal either and just because they sell
the product doesn't mean they are experts at fixing them - - pick a dealer or
shop where they like what they sell and care how the product runs.
Another factor that may enter into the picture is that some cars do not
have adjustments on the suspension so if the hot appearing wheel package is
what you have to have then you may nave to live with whatever handling
changes or deficiencies that show up after the fact. Having said that, sometimes
the change in the vehicles handling characteristics is the goal along with the
appearance, and if this is the case then great! |